a NEW wheel. If he refuses take a chain to his bike. Then call it even. I must congratulate you on being so calm, had it been me I would have cut the chain and pushed his bike in the middle of the road. But then thats just me, I can't stand assholes like him.....10pm goddam it a business they don't usually operate at 10pm. He damaged your property he should no MUST be held accountable...you know you can be an asshole right back at him...I say take it out on the bike.